HIS THROAT CUT.
_____
MYSTERY AND A
BARLOW KNIFE AT
FARMERS' BRANCH.
______
A Case of
Murder or Suicide -- The Body of
a Strange Young Man Unidentified.
Inquiries Made by a Strange
Young Woman Recalled.
The body of an unknown man [Ira B. Oliver] was found on the river bank at
the mouth of Farmers' Branch, five miles from the town of Farmers' Branch,
yesterday, and Justice Skelton inquested it, but without identifying it.
The deceased was a young man with clean-shaven face, dressed in jeans
pants, home-made drawers and socks, partially worn shoes and a common $.50 hat.
His hands were tender and evidently not accustomed to recent hard work. There
was some wheat chaff in his pockets and thresher dust on his hat and clothes,
indicating that he had either been working or sleeping about a threshing
machine. But, there was nothing on him by which he could be identified.
His throat was cut and a Barlow knife with a dirk blade open was found
lying on the ground near him.
One theory is that he suicided and another is that he was murdered.
Justice Skelton ascertained at Farmers' Branch, that several days ago, a
woman from Grapevine came up to that place on one train and went back on the
next, making inquiry about her husband.
Sheriff Cabell, who is making a thorough investigation of the matter, says
that, so far, he has discovered nothing pointing to the identity of the man, and
he is unprepared to say whether it was a case of suicide or murder.
Sheriff Cabell said this afternoon that he had reason to believe the dead
man's name is Crowell, but could learn nothing else about him.
- July 14, 1894, Dallas Daily Times Herald, p. 3, col.
3.
AMOS BREWER
MAKES A STATEMENT
______
HE WAS THE LAST
COMPANION OF
IRA B. OLIVER.
_______
All the
Circumstances That Have Come to
Light Tend to Show That Oliver, in a
Fit of Despondency, Commit-
ted Suicide.
Sheriff Cabell arrived this morning from Fannin county, accompanied by
Amos Brewer, the young man who traveled with Ira B. Oliver from Fannin county to
Farmers Branch in this county, and there left him a few miles from where the
dead body of Oliver was found, with the throat cut, full details of which have
already appeared in the TIMES HERALD.
Brewer is a typical farmer boy, about 19 or 20 years old. He stated that
he left Fannin county with Oliver and went to Renner, where they worked with a
thresher and stopped with a Mr. Smith. From there, they went to Farmers Branch
in search of work, but finding none, they separated, Brewer returning to Fannin,
and Oliver going in the direction of Fort Worth, the one first striking work to
write the other. This was the last Brewer saw of Oliver.
Sheriff Cabell produced the hat, shoes, shirt, vest, bandana handkerchief
and knife of the dead man. Brewer readily identified them as belonging to
Oliver.
Brewer said that Oliver was usually of a cheerful disposition, but that he
had recently taken to drink and this seemed to give him gloomy fits. The day
before separating from him, Brewer says Oliver remarked that this thing of being
away from home and out of work was distressing, and he would as soon be dead as
to be in such a fix. This was all Brewer ever heard him say in regard to being
weary of life.
Sheriff Cabell had the county attorney to take Brewer's statement in
writing. It was the desire to thoroughly sift this matter that Mr. Cabell went
to the trouble and expense of bringing Brewer to Dallas, and he says the further
he investigates the case, the more he is convinced that it was suicide.
Young Brewer will return home this evening.
- July 18, 1894, Dallas Daily Times Herald, p. 6, col. 2.
BREWER CHARGED
WITH MURDER.
_____
THE MYSTERY OF
IRA B. OLIVER'S
DEATH BEING SOLVED.
______
The Story of
Suicide Giving Place to That
of Foul Play -- Brewer Will Have an
Examining Trial To-morrow
or Saturday.
A few weeks ago, the dead body of Ira B. Oliver, with his throat
cut from ear to ear, was found on the river bank at the mouth of Farmers'
branch.
It was generally believed, at the time, that Oliver was a farmer boy in
search of work, and had, in a fit of despondency, committed suicide.
Amos Brewer, a young man who worked with Oliver in Collin county, and who
traveled with him until the morning of the day on which he is supposed to have
suicided, went back to Fannin county, the place they originally started from.
Brewer was brought to Dallas by Sheriff Cabell to make a statement, after
which he was permitted to return to Fannin county.
Here lately, new evidence has been discovered, and an affidavit was made
before Justice Malone, of Richardson, charging Brewer with the murder of Oliver,
and Sheriff Cabell got in with Brewer last night and lodged him in jail. He will
have an examining trial to-morrow or Saturday.
- August 2, 1894, Dallas Daily Times Herald, p. 2, col. 5.
HIS SWEETHEART
GAVE HIM AWAY.
________
MISS WILLIAMS
SAYS BREWER TOLD
HER HE KILLED OLIVER.
_______
She Will This
Afternoon Confront the Pris-
oner Before Justice Malone of Car-
rollton and Tell What He
Confided to Her.
Sheriff Cabell left on the noon train for Carrollton, having in charge,
Amos Brewer, who will have an examining trail this afternoon before Justice C.
E. Malone of Precinct No. 2, on charge of being the slayer of Ira B. Oliver,
whose dead body was found near the mouth of Farmers Branch about a month ago.
At the time of the inquest, Brewer, who had been a fellow farm hand of
Oliver, made a statement regarded as conclusively exculpating him from any hand
in the taking off of Oliver. It is not now believed by the officials that Brewer
is guilty, but the alleged discovery of new evidence made it necessary to arrest
and try him.
Assistant County Attorney Littleton went to Carrollton to represent the
state in the trail.
Barry Miller and Green Williams go along to defend Brewer.
Green Williams stated to a TIMES HERALD reporter that the new testimony
discovered is the statement of a Miss Williams, who claims that Brewer told her
that he had killed Oliver in the afternoon of the day on which Brewer and Oliver
are supposed to have separated at Mr. Connor's house, Brewer to return to Fannin
county and Oliver going in the opposite direction. Brewer reached the home of
Miss Williams' parents and stopped. Miss Williams says Brewer told her about the
murder.
The testimony against Brewer at the trial this afternoon will be the
statement of Miss Williams.
- August 4, 1894, Dallas Daily Times Herald, p. 6, col.
DID AMOS BREWER
KILL IRA OLIVER?
______
MISS WILLIAMS
SWEARS HE CON-
FESSED TO HER.
______
Jealousy the
Apparent Cause of the Crime.
The Investigation Begun Saturday
Before Justice Malone at Carroll-
ton and Adjourned to Dallas.
The examining trial of Amos Brewer, charged with the murder of Ira B.
Oliver, which was commenced before Justice C. E. Malone, of Precinct No. 2,
at Carrollton, last Saturday, was adjourned to Dallas to-day, but owing to the
absence of some of the witnesses, it was further adjourned to be resumed at
Richardson on Wednesday.
Miss Winnie Williams was the only witness examined Saturday. Miss Williams
is 16 years old, and keeps house for her brother on a farm near Carrollton. She
testified that Oliver and Brewer stopped at her brother's house and she got
acquainted with both of them. At about noon of the day on which the two men had
separated in the morning, and on which Oliver is supposed to have met his death,
Brewer stopped at her house on his way back to Fannin county and said he had a
secret to confide to her. He told her he had killed Oliver, because he had told
him a few lies and because she seemed to give Oliver the preference over him. He
further said he had killed him for very slight provocation, and if he could
recall the deed, he would not do it again.
Those who heard Miss Williams' testimony say she made a very
straightforward statement.
John W. Oliver, father of the dead man, was here to attend the trial. He
lives at Milan, Tennessee. He says his son never knew Brewer until he came to
Texas.
O. M. Thornton, a brother-in-law of the dead man, is also here. He lives
in Fannin county. He says Ira B. Oliver helped him make a crop this year, and
after it was laid by, he started across the country to visit a friend in the
Nation. It was on this journey he fell in with Brewer, who evidently got him to
go out of his way, as the route he took will show. He says Oliver was not
looking for work, nor hard up for money, as he had a home and an interest in a
crop with him, and could, anytime, get any moderate sum of money for the asking,
from either him or John W. Oliver.
Both the father and brother-in-law say Ira was very boyish for his age,
which was 19 years, and of a cheerful disposition and enjoyed good health, and
that he never suicided. They are satisfied that Brewer killed him.
Sheriff Cabell says he has no statement to make at the present.
- August 6, 1894, Dallas Daily Times Herald, p. 4, col. 4.
"The testimony shows that on the morning Oliver and
Brewer separated, Oliver left Mrs. Connor's house at 7 o'clock, going west. Two
hours later, Brewer left and followed the same road a short distance, and was
seen to take the fork leading to the east. At 11 o'clock, while still holding on
his easterly course, Brewer fell in with Mr. Frick in a wagon, and rode with
him. Mr. Frick says his conversation was that of a country boy. He talked of his
home and what kind of work he did. He also spoke of his friend, Oliver, and said
he tried to get him to return East with him. Mr. Frick said he was not excited
in the least, and did not appear to have anything weighing on his mind.
"It was late in the afternoon of the same day when
Brewer reached Miss Williams' house and, she says, made a confession to her.
This was on the 11th. The same evening, Miss Williams told her married sister
what Brewer had confided to her. But, neither of the ladies told anybody else,
and the body was not found until the 13th, when some persons fishing, discovered
it about one and a half miles beyond the home of Mr. Connor, where Oliver was
last seen alive. Miss Williams said nothing about the secret she had until last
week.
"We are still working on the case. I am going to
Farmer's Branch this evening. I don't know what may come of the case."
-
August 9, 1894, Dallas Daily Times Herald, p. 6, col. 1-2.
GOES FREE.
____
THE JURY SAYS
NOT GUILTY.
____
Adjudged Not to
Have Shot Ira B. Oliver in
the Back and Cut His Head Nearly
From the Shoulders -- Farmers
Branch Mystery Unsolved.
The jury in the Amos Brewer murder case were out just ten minutes, when
they brought in a verdict of acquittal.
____
Brewer was indicted for the murder of Ira B. Oliver near Farmers
Branch last July, with the details, of which TIMES HERALD readers are familiar.
Brewer and Oliver had been working together, and on the day of the death
of Oliver, they separated, near where the body was found, Brewer to return to
his home near Paris, and Oliver to go to Fannin county in search of work.
Every one of the State's witnesses corroborated Brewer's statement in
detail, except Miss Minnie Williams, who testified that Brewer told her he
killed Oliver. At the inquest, the only wound found on Oliver was where his
throat had been cut. But, Miss Williams testified on the examining trial of
Brewer that Brewer told her he first shot Oliver in the back of the head and
then cut his throat. The body of Oliver was then exhumed and a bullet hole found
in the back of his head.
____
The State failed to prove any motive for the murder.
____
Brewer, a mere boy, was cool in deportment and straightforward and
perfectly consistent in his statements throughout, by which he made a most
favorable impression on the court and jury and spectators.
Yet, the mysterious part of the matter to everybody is how Miss Williams
knew about the bullet hole in the back of Oliver's head. Somebody that knew must
have told her about it.
- February 26, 1895, Dallas Daily Times Herald, p. 1, col. 5.
|